Charles de Gaulle, the French President who led his nation towards Nazi Germany as soon as famously stated,”Patriotism is when love of your individual folks comes first; nationalism, when hate for folks aside from your individual comes first.”
This stark distinction between patriotism and nationalism is now extra obvious than ever, with the latter resurgent around the globe in a means that calls into query the emotions hundreds of thousands of people that love their respective nations, races and religions have for one another. Is it love for “our folks,” or hate for “others?”
The occasions at Capitol Hill on January 6 have been known as an assault on democracy by a riotous mob and a fascist act incited by a rogue President. Whereas these descriptions could also be correct, they don’t establish the emotion that motivated a whole bunch of individuals from across the nation to assemble at Capitol Hill, to have interaction in violence whereas on digital camera, and to place their very own lives and livelihoods on the road with the intention to forestall what they have been led to imagine was a grave injustice. That underlying emotion was one in all hate and indignation, and it was build up lengthy earlier than Donald Trump turned President. Trump solely accelerated its progress, serving as a catalyst to assist it attain a tipping level till it discovered expression within the violence final Wednesday that claimed 5 lives.
Assist Us Finish 2020 with 1000 Supporters!
Alhamdulillah, we’re at 900 supporters. Assist us get to 1000 supporters earlier than 2020 ends. All it takes is a small reward from a reader such as you to maintain us going, for simply $2 / month.
The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the most effective of deeds are those who carried out constantly, even when they’re small.
Click on right here to assist MuslimMatters with a month-to-month donation of $2 per 30 days. Set it and accumulate blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you are supporting with out enthusiastic about it.
The Capitol Hill assault, whereas rightfully thought-about as a darkish chapter in US historical past, didn’t occur in isolation. The mainstreaming of far-right concepts as soon as espoused solely by fringe teams, is a part of a worldwide sample of a number of nations gravitating in direction of virulent types of nationalism. From the recognition of the rabid Hindu nationalist authorities in India and the rise of Buddhist “nationalist” forces cheerleading the genocide of the Rohingya in Myanmar to the Ku Klux Klan discovering frequent trigger with the US President, a whole bunch of hundreds of thousands of individuals around the globe are actually more and more figuring out with (and voting for) a story that entails by some means restoring a “nationwide glory” whose loss may be attributed to the “others,” normally immigrants, minorities and other people of shade.
The truth that hundreds of thousands of Trump voters proceed to imagine the election was rigged is just not unrelated to the truth that the QAnon conspiracy principle motion, regarded by the FBI to pose a home terrorism menace now has their first elected consultant to the US Home of Representatives. Just like the canard perpetuated by Hindu nationalist forces that 200 million Indian Muslims are “traitors” to their nation, a few of whom have been marrying Hindu ladies as a part of a “Love Jihad” marketing campaign to subvert Hindu society, the QAnon motion has managed to get a web-based following of people that imagine Trump is up towards a cabal of Devil-worshipping, cannibalistic pedophiles that’s working a worldwide youngster sex-trafficking ring. Within the age of pretend information and social media, the megaphones of falsehoods and smear campaigns are louder and extra highly effective than ever, and so they threaten not solely legislation and order, however the very thought of what’s meant by common will.
Ought to we be intimidated by the assist that “sturdy males” like Trump and Modi get pleasure from of their respective nations, or query the underlying falsehoods that catapulted these males to energy?
Is Aung San Suu Kyi’s tacit assist for the Rohingya genocide, together with a protection of Myanmar on the Worldwide Court docket, by some means much less alarming as a result of she continues to be extraordinarily common in Myanmar?
In a lot as these leaders got here to energy by democratic elections, with every having an ardent following of hundreds of thousands keen to take to the streets for them, they symbolize the desire of their supporters. In that sense, even the shameful assault on the Capitol was, within the phrases of John Harris of Politico, “a perverse expression of democracy.”
Nevertheless there’s one thread that’s frequent to all nationalist actions, from Nazism in World II Germany and Hindutva in India to the white supremacist forces within the West. It’s a reliance on narratives that weaponize actual or perceived grievances, on a revisionism of historical past that holds the “different” liable for virtually the whole lot that ails the Republic and that falsely claims that the options to the nation’s complicated issues are predicated on a subjugation of its minorities.
Unfettered social media has amplified these hateful ideologies which have every been constructed round an online of lies and deceit. Whereas these have various causes, the results on their victims comply with very related trajectories. Alienation, discrimination, demonization and much too usually, horrific mass violence. Hate speech could also be as previous because the human race, however the means to amplify and disseminate it to a worldwide viewers have by no means been as highly effective and its results by no means as deadly as they’re at the moment. There exists ample proof within the public area that incendiary rhetoric on-line, particularly by influential teams and people, has led to precise violence that has destroyed numerous lives in India, Myanmar and different nations. It’s not stunning that the “aggrieved” majorities in these nations are becoming a member of fingers, as outlined in a New York Occasions article in 2014 titled “Lethal Alliances towards Muslims.”
Whereas folks of conscience around the globe agree on the necessity to problem these false narratives, it is crucial we focus on the phrases of such a problem, whether it is to even make a dent within the trajectory of those hate actions. To say that the rioting “nationalist” mob at Capitol Hill final Wednesday was pushed by sentiments of hate is stating the apparent. The tougher query is how we will rise above hating them! To retreat into our secure areas the place our views are pushed by a shared set of info is straightforward. To confront the bigger downside, of how faux information and the widespread abuse of social media are pushing false narratives which in flip gasoline hate and anger, is tough.
Due to exposes of Fb’s corrupt dealing with of hate and Islamophobia, two of which have been printed within the Wall Road Journal and one in Time, the general public is now conscious of the a number of failures of ethics and legality on the social media large. Nevertheless, this isn’t even scratching the floor by way of how false narratives are purposefully disseminated over time, in ways in which they develop into a part of the discourse. An enormous examine of pretend information undertaken by MIT discovered that falsehoods constantly dominate the reality on Twitter. The examine analyzed 126,000 tales, tweeted by three million customers over 10 years.
“We should redesign our info ecosystem within the 21st century,” declared a gaggle of 16 political scientists and authorized students in an essay printed in Science.
There aren’t any winners when hate and falsehood develop into pervasive. The genocide of Rohingya has not introduced prosperity to Myanmar, and the demonization of Muslims in India together with numerous lynchings has not helped the nation avert a document fall in its GDP.It’s due to this fact necessary for folks of conscience around the globe to rally across the purpose of defending each citizen’s proper to the reality. Pretend information, social media and hate are a deadly mixture, and left unchecked, they’ll collectively devour the whole lot defines our humanity, together with our God-given mandate to discern reality from falsehood.
Hating and demonizing those that attacked Capitol Hill might assist a few of us let steam out with the intention to take care of the trauma of current occasions. Within the bigger scheme of issues nevertheless, it’s our means to strategize round long run initiatives and efficient coalitions and to make use of our restricted assets in methods that may have probably the most affect that can decide how this problem to humanity is in the end defeated. In different phrases, it’s our tenacity in defending the reality and braveness in taking over falsehoods that’s dealing with a check.